Atlantis Online
April 19, 2024, 11:23:53 pm
Welcome, Guest. Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
News: Scientists Confirm Historic Massive Flood in Climate Change
http://www.giss.nasa.gov/research/news/20060228/
 
  Home Help Arcade Gallery Links Staff List Calendar Login Register  

Best Books on Atlantis

Pages: [1] 2   Go Down
  Print  
Author Topic: Best Books on Atlantis  (Read 1836 times)
0 Members and 36 Guests are viewing this topic.
Athena Nike
Superhero Member
******
Posts: 2209



« on: April 12, 2007, 02:05:23 am »

Let's toss a few names of books out there dealing with the Atlantis theme, discuss the pros and cons of each one, and see if we can decide which are the best ones, as well as try and compile a complete list.

Here are just a few to start with:

The Timaeus and Critias By Plato.

Published in English by Penguin Classics.

What better place to commence any investigation of the Atlantis saga than reading what Plato actually wrote on the subject. Although by no means all of the Timaeus and Critias is devoted to the Atlantis account it still constitutes an irresistible source of reference for anyone at all interested in the story.

The Secret of Atlantis by Otto Muck.

German title: Alles uber Atlantis.

Originally published in Germany by Econ Verlag GmbH 1976

Published in English by William Collins 1978.

An extraordinary book that gives exhaustive proof of several of the key elements of the Atlantis debate. It convincingly argues that not only was Atlantis an Atlantic Island but that given certain catastrophic circumstances Atlantis could indeed have disappeared beneath the waves in a single day and night as recounted by the Greek philosopher Plato. We believe that no other book in the Atlantis debate does so much towards proving the existence of this long lost island. A masterpiece of scholarly deduction.

The Mystery of Atlantis by Charles Berlitz.

First published in Great Britain by Souvenir Press 1976.

A popular well rounded book that ably explores the many different aspects of the Atlantis story. Although the authors support for the idea of the historical existence of Atlantis is obvious, this is in no way allowed to colour the thrust of his arguments. Much of this material can be found in other books on the subject but Berlitz’s style of writing makes for a painless job of comprehension.

History of Atlantis by Lewis Spence.

First published by Rider& Company, London 1926

Lately published by Studio Editions, London 1995.

For years this was virtually required reading for anyone even slightly interested in the Atlantis mystery. Author Lewis Spence wrote at least five books on the Atlantis theme of which this is the most popular. It illustrates the various cultural, zoological, and geographical clues that make the prospect of an historical Atlantis in the Atlantic Ocean a distinct possibility. However despite this approbation of Plato’s account, author Spence attempts to show that although Atlantis existed it was not the supremely extraordinary place of modern imagining but something of an advanced ‘stone-age’ civilisation similar to that of ancient Mexico and Peru.

Atlantis in Santorini.

The theme of Atlantis in terms of its location on the Greek island of Santorini- Thira - as it also called, has led to the publication of a whole host of books. Several of the best known ones are listed below.

Voyage to Atlantis by James W Mavor.

First published in Great Britain by Souvenir Press 1969

The importance of Santorini as an archaeological site of prime importance is not in doubt. Nor is the fact that Santorini was blown apart by a massive volcanic explosion around 1300 BC. An explosion which not only ripped apart the island but effectively put an end to the Minoan civilisation on the nearby island of Crete. What is in doubt however, and what is never satisfactorily explained in this book is why Santorini should be mistaken for Atlantis when Plato specifically says it was over 2500 miles away in the Atlantic Ocean.

The End of Atlantis by J.V. Luce

First published by Thames & Hudson Ltd, London 1969

This is yet another attempt to attribute the location of Atlantis to the island of Santorini in Greece. A profoundly scholarly work but suffering from the unresolved flaw of the above mentioned book - namely the difficulty of overriding Plato’s insistence that Atlantis was an Atlantic Island.

Atlantis of the North by Jurgen Spanuth

First published in Great Britain by Sidgwick and Jackson Ltd 1979

First published in Germany under the title Die Atlanter by Grabert-Verlag

In some senses this expertly written book deserves much claim and attention. In fact were it not for the fact that here again the author strives assiduously to make Atlantis into a kingdom off the coast of northern Europe it would be a phenomenal work of scholarship. Why for instance would Plato be so specific: That Atlantis was just beyond the Pillars of Hercules - if in fact it was actually an island off the coast of modern Germany. This aside “Atlantis of the North”, is a great account of other sunken lands that might indeed have been Atlantean colonies, but not the island itself.

http://www.returntoatlantis.com/retc/books.html
Report Spam   Logged

Share on Facebook Share on Twitter

Kothar Bishop
Superhero Member
******
Posts: 1893



« Reply #1 on: April 22, 2007, 05:09:15 am »

To which I would also add:









Report Spam   Logged
Kothar Bishop
Superhero Member
******
Posts: 1893



« Reply #2 on: April 22, 2007, 05:11:38 am »

And:










Report Spam   Logged
Kothar Bishop
Superhero Member
******
Posts: 1893



« Reply #3 on: April 22, 2007, 05:13:55 am »

And finally:











Report Spam   Logged
cleasterwood
Hero Member
*****
Posts: 246



WWW
« Reply #4 on: April 22, 2007, 06:50:04 am »

I have the Atlantis Encyclopedia and man is it packed with information.  And even though I don't agree with Joseph's background or the fact he places Atlantis in the 1000 BC range, it has a lot of resources that do add up.  Smiley  And you may not believe this but if you're looking for channeled research try "The Ra Materials".  There are several volumes now and it has tons of channeled information about Atlantis and the Confederacy of Planets, which we haven't met yet I suppose.   Wink
Report Spam   Logged

Ra's Warrior & the Talismans of Time!  http://www.talismansoftime.com
rockessence
Superhero Member
******
Posts: 1688


Using rocks and minerals to heal the earth and us.


WWW
« Reply #5 on: April 23, 2007, 02:43:48 am »



The Untold Story of One Man's Quest for a Lost World

In 1679, Renaissance man Olof Rudbeck stunned the world. He proposed that an ancient lost civilization once thrived in the far north of his native Sweden: the fabled Atlantis. Rudbeck would spend the last thirty years of his life hunting for the evidence that would prove this extraordinary theory.

Chasing down clues to that lost golden age, Rudbeck combined the reasoning of Sherlock Holmes with the daring of Indiana Jones. He excavated what he thought was the acropolis of Atlantis, retraced the journeys of classical heroes, opened countless burial mounds, and consulted rich collections of manuscripts and artifacts. He eventually published his findings in a 2,500-page tome titled Atlantica, a remarkable work replete with heroic quests, exotic lands, and fabulous creatures.

Three hundred years later, the story of Rudbeck’s adventures appears in English for the first time. It is a thrilling narrative of discovery as well as a cautionary tale about the dangerous dance of genius and madness.

Finding Atlantis
By: King, David

The untold story of a fascinating Renaissance man on an adventurous hunt for a lost civilization—an epic quest through castles, courts, mythologies, and the spectacular world of the imagination.

What do Zeus, Apollo, and the gods of Mount Olympus have in common with Odin, Thor, and the gods of Valhalla? What do these, in turn, have to do with the shades of Hades, the pharaohs of Egypt, and the glories of fabled Atlantis? In 1679, Olof Rudbeck stunned the world with the answer: They could all be traced to an ancient lost civilization that once thrived in the far north of Rudbeck’s native Sweden. He would spend the last thirty years of his life hunting for the evidence that would prove this extraordinary theory.

Chasing down clues to that lost golden age, Rudbeck combined the reasoning of Sherlock Holmes with the daring of Indiana Jones. He excavated what he thought was the acropolis of Atlantis, retraced the journeys of classical heroes, opened countless burial mounds, and consulted rich collections of manuscripts and artifacts. He eventually published his findings in a 2,500-page tome titled Atlantica, a remarkable work replete with heroic quests, exotic lands, and fabulous creatures.

Three hundred years later, the story of Rudbeck’s adventures appears in English for the first time. It is a thrilling narrative of discovery as well as a cautionary tale about the dangerous dance of genius and madness.


From the Hardcover edition. 

Excerpt
Chapter 1: Promises

My dear fellow, life is infinitely stranger than anything which the mind of man could invent. —Arthur Conan Doyle, The Hound of the Baskervilles

Some fifty years before the great fire, Olof Rudbeck had arrived as a young student at Uppsala University. This was in the cold and dark winter of 1648, just in time for the enthusiastic celebrations that would soon erupt on the Continent, marking the signing of the Peace of Westphalia and an end, it was hoped, to thirty years of the most vicious fighting that Europe had ever known. War, famine, plague, and plunder had decimated the populations, spreading misery everywhere the armies marched. Now the clang of church bells and the clatter of court banquets might replace the roar of cannon and the cries of suffering. Musketeers fired joyous salvoes into the air, and soaring bonfires were lit to commemorate the news. The festivities were especially lively in Sweden, already “drunk with victory and bloated with booty.”

Uppsala University was at this time the jewel in the crown of the Swedish kingdom. Although the university had fallen into disuse a few years after its establishment in 1477, the state had realized its enormous potential as a training ground for the new Protestant Reformation and reopened it with royal flair. Young people came from all corners of the realm to learn the theology and acquire the intellectual rigor required to enter the Church. The university also attracted the scions of the great aristocratic houses, sons of the landed and titled families who waged Sweden’s wars, administered the empire, and served the Crown in countless other capacities. King Gustavus Adolphus, the famed “Lion of the North,” had envisioned just such a role for Uppsala University. He had endowed it with the means to realize it as well, even filling its empty bookshelves with many magnificent collections looted from an almost unbroken string of victories on the battlefield.

Rudbeck was neither a nobleman nor an aspirant to a career in the Church, though he was thrilled all the same to enter the halls of Scandinavia’s oldest university. This was understandably an exciting place for a young man. Despite repeated efforts of the authorities, students flocked to the taverns as much as to the lecture halls. Entertainment options ranged from dice to duels. It was already becoming common for students to carry swords, and sometimes even pistols. New brothels opened to meet the increasing demand, and other institutions emerged to serve the changing times, such as the university prison. Housed in the cellars of the main university building, the prison was rarely unoccupied.

Rudbeck’s interests, however, lay elsewhere. Ever since he was a boy, he had enjoyed finding his own way. He sang, he drew, he played the lute, he even made his own toys, including a wooden clock with a bell to strike the hour. Adventurous and independent, Rudbeck yearned to experience the world for himself. In fact, as a ten-year-old, Rudbeck had eagerly tried to follow his older brothers to Uppsala. His father, however, would not allow it, convinced that he was not mature enough to handle the freedom of the university.

Standing tall and giving the impression of no small confidence, Rudbeck was a spirited, highly impressionable youth with short dark hair, broad shoulders, and a barrel chest. He walked, or rather strode, with the air of someone who fearlessly plunged into his latest passion. His imagination, at this time, was fired by the study of anatomy. This was an especially attractive subject for bright, ambitious students. Kings and queens had showered favors on the talented few they chose as royal physicians, and indeed the newly established post of court physician had raised the status of the doctor from its previously undistinguished connotations. Enthusiasm for medicine as an intellectual pursuit peaked when an Englishman named William Harvey published a small Latin treatise in 1628.

Harvey was one of those elite court physicians, serving King James I of England. In his classic De Motu Cordis et Sanguinis (Dissertation on the Movement of the Heart and Blood), Harvey claimed that the heart was a muscle that pumped the blood at regular intervals, or pulses. The vital fluid circulated throughout the body, with the arteries carrying it away from the heart and the veins returning it there. With these propositions, Harvey had revolutionized the study of medicine. One Oxford doctor and fellow of the Royal Society claimed that these findings were more significant than the discovery of America because they threw centuries of medical belief into uncertainty. Great physicians everywhere now wanted to confirm, refute, or refine Harvey’s propositions.

It was in this climate that Olof Rudbeck entered the medical school at Uppsala. His head was full of ideas, his curiosity almost boundless. He could not wait to be turned loose to investigate for himself the mysterious invisible world underneath the skin. But unfortunately the university had very little to offer. Rudbeck’s supervisor was too busy for him, preferring instead to spend time in the alchemy lab, trying to change various substances into gold. More challenging still, it was difficult to gain access to the necessary equipment. When acquiring human bodies for observation and dissection was a difficult task even for a professor, what could a student do?

One crisp autumn day in 1650, Rudbeck strolled down to the market, a bustling square jammed with carts, stalls, and stands. There were stacks of cheese, slabs of butter, and fish, gutted and stretched out. Gloves of fine goat-hair and warm wolfskin coats also competed for attention. Rudbeck’s eye, however, fell on two women, rough and splattered with blood, as they butchered a calf. There, in the raw dead flesh, Rudbeck saw something peculiar. There was a milklike substance that seemed to emanate from somewhere in the chest, not so delicately split open on the old bench. His curiosity was piqued, and an idea suddenly struck him. With the enthusiasm of someone who had long enjoyed taking things apart and tinkering to see how they worked, Rudbeck asked if he could cut on the carcass.

The women must have been surprised, to say the least, at this young man’s request. With their permission granted, Rudbeck borrowed the knife, forced the thick, lifeless aorta to the side, and then separated it from the surrounding red mess of muscle and tissue. He followed that curious milk-like substance along, finding a sort of vessel or duct that carried a colorless liquid. By the time he traced it back to the liver, the dark purplish brown organ undoubtedly destined for dinner fare, he knew he was onto something big.

Rudbeck had discovered nothing less than the lymphatic system. The colorless liquid was lymph, a tissue-cleansing fluid vital to the functioning of the body’s immune system. Among other things, it absorbs nutrients, collects fats, and prevents harmful substances from entering the bloodstream. He not only discovered this system but also correctly explained its functions in the body.

This episode clearly shows a resourcefulness that would long be a hallmark of Rudbeck’s approach to problem-solving. As William Harvey improved his knowledge of anatomy by investigating the deer bagged by King James and the royal hunting parties, Rudbeck the student relied on the successful meat trade of Uppsala’s butchers. Over the next two years, probably working in a dingy makeshift shed by the river, Rudbeck set his dissection table with a veritable smorgasbord of discarded delicacies. He cut, nipped, hacked, and examined, performing hundreds of dissections and vivisections to refine his practical understanding of the body’s cleansing mechanisms.

Rudbeck’s explanation of the lymphatic system was indeed a major discovery in the annals of modern medicine—the first, in fact, to come from a Swedish scientist. It was also a fulfillment of William Harvey’s theories of the circulation of the blood, which were then still fiercely contested. In distant Uppsala, the young Rudbeck, not even twenty years old, had confirmed one of the greatest medical discoveries of the day.

Word of this remarkable student spread quickly through the Swedish kingdom, and soon reached its colorful queen. Like Greta Garbo, who played her in the film, Queen Christina has intrigued historians just as she fascinated her contemporaries. She was young, barely twenty-six years old, and somewhat shorter than medium height, with thick, curly, dark brown hair often tied with a simple black ribbon. Her voice was soft but deep, and her eyes piercing. Whenever she was displeased, it soon became abundantly clear, the queen’s face darkened like a “thunder cloud.” Eight years of power had accustomed her to doing exactly as she wished. Controversy, though, was never far away.

Rumors had long circulated that the Swedish queen was a nymphomaniac, a lesbian, a man in disguise, or perhaps a hermaphrodite. After all, when she was born, the midwife first took her for a boy, and even told the king that he had a new son. The hermaphrodite belief was dispelled only when a team of international experts, restoring her grave in the 1920s, decided to take a look. The queen, they confirmed, had indeed been a woman.

Despite all differences of opinion, her admirers and critics agreed on one point: Queen Christina attracted some of the best and brightest of the day. During her short reign, a motley collection of cavaliers, ladies, libertines, and scholars streamed to her court. Perhaps the most famous of these was René Descartes. There was probably no thinker of the day more idolized than this French philosopher.

Indeed, when he arrived in Stockholm, Descartes soon found himself taxed by Queen Christina’s enthusiasm for early-morning lessons in the new thought, and equally burdensome demands to compose ballets for entertainment in the evening. The Frenchman, overworked and exhausted, succumbed to an unusually cold winter in Christina’s unusually cold castle. He died in February 1650, after shivering through five miserable months at court (though his skull, it turned out, stayed in the country almost two hundred years longer; it had been secretly removed and replaced with a substitute, and was not reunited with his body in France until 1821).

It was now Olof Rudbeck’s turn to come to Queen Christina’s court. She was much impressed by his anatomical work and sent an invitation for the student to present his discoveries to her in person. On a beautiful spring day in 1652, Rudbeck arrived at the royal castle in Uppsala.

Set majestically on the highest hilltop, the castle overlooked the town barely a stone’s cast away from the cathedral. Construction of the castle, begun by King Gustav Vasa in the 1540s, was still unfinished. Only two sides of the desired square had been completed, and the surrounding hillside was overgrown with weeds. On the inside, though, the castle was decorated with treasures including paintings, tapestries, statues, and almost anything else of value that Swedish armies could pack up in chests and carry back to the north.

Like many distinguished guests before him, Rudbeck marched up to the castle, climbed the stone steps, and entered the great hall. As the court looked on, the twenty-one-year-old demonstrated his medical discovery. Queen Christina was dazzled. She never had to tap her fan in impatience, or play distractedly with her spaniels. She just sat transfixed on her crimson velvet cushion with eyes aglow at the spectacle. The courtiers saw a new rising star, and the queen did too. By the end of the day she had offered Rudbeck a royal scholarship to continue his studies at Leiden University. He left the castle, his ears ringing with praise and head spinning with anticipation.

Sweden was, at this time, one of the most powerful countries in the world. Despite its small population, thinly scattered throughout the kingdom, Sweden had burst upon the scene in 1630, the year of Rudbeck’s birth, with some dazzling victories in the Thirty Years’ War. King Gustavus Adolphus’s army was praised as the best in the world, and his advanced, modernized bureaucracy was, as one observer put it, the envy of France. By the end of the war in 1648, and Rudbeck’s eighteenth birthday, Sweden had emerged with France as the guarantor of Europe’s peace.

Swedish territory then encircled the Baltic Sea and its sweet-smelling pine forests, its flat, marshy heaths, and its foggy pebble beaches. The blue and gold Swedish flag was raised in Finland, northern Germany, the modern Baltic states, and as far away as Cabo Corso on the African Gold Coast. There was even a “New Sweden” confidently planted in America on the Delaware River, including today’s Trenton and Philadelphia.

Rudbeck’s country had never been more powerful or more influential. Exports boomed, and its merchants, at first mostly Dutch immigrants, dominated some of the most lucrative trades of the day. Sweden was Europe’s unrivaled producer of copper and iron, and of the manufactured products that relied on these materials, such as cannon, cannonballs, and lightweight, quick-loading muskets. Lands in its Baltic dominion produced timber, hemp, flax, pitch, and tar, no small advantage in a warlike world just coming to appreciate the advantages of sea power. One Danish historian has compared the Baltic Sea in the seventeenth century to the Persian Gulf in the twentieth: though much of the region was undeveloped and remote, it was the source of scarce raw materials absolutely central to the functioning of the world at the time.

The capital of the kingdom, Stockholm, had grown rich controlling this trade, already boasting a stunning panorama of buildings, bridges, and water that would later earn it the name “Venice of the North.” The docks were bustling, too, with men unloading crates into the warehouses along the seafront. Horses drawing carriages clip-clopped down the cobblestone lanes, passing the fine buildings, the noble estates, and the brick churches with copper spires. Down in the center of the capital, tucked away in the Old Town, stood the Stockholm Banco, preparing, in just a few years, to issue the world’s first modern paper currency. All told, diligence and decadence went together in creating the period Swedish historians call the “age of greatness.”

But the small wooden huts clustering in the shadows of the towering mansions were reminders of another side to Sweden’s imperial age. For every laced-up, velvet-clad courtier enjoying Italian perfumes, there were many others who toiled under brutal conditions. As many as 90 percent of the population were peasants, squeezing out a tenuous existence on small homesteads, or bound under steep feudal obligations on large manors. Less fortunate still were the many victims of the recent wars. Armless veterans begged in the streets, and legions of orphans roamed in search of food. In desperation, many women became prostitutes, and some people joined the rogues hiding out in forests, preying upon the secluded roadways.

Olof Rudbeck had grown up in this environment of power and poverty. His home was Västerås, then one of the largest towns in the country, and visibly prospering from the “great quantities of copper and iron, digged [sic] out of the mines.” At the very center stood the cathedral, a restored Gothic structure with a long, tapering spire rising high above its surroundings, and in fact, at that time, the tallest in Sweden. The town also had a castle and even its own curious “wizard” who once, it was said, “made wings and flew, but broke one of his legs.”




http://www.ebooks.com/ebooks/book_display.asp?IID=222582
Report Spam   Logged

ILLIGITIMI NON CARBORUNDUM

Thus ye may find in thy mental and spiritual self, ye can make thyself just as happy or just as miserable as ye like. How miserable do ye want to be?......For you GROW to heaven, you don't GO to heaven. It is within thine own conscience that ye grow there.

Edgar Cayce
Ian Nottingham
Superhero Member
******
Posts: 3441



« Reply #6 on: April 23, 2007, 11:35:42 pm »

I've actually heard of this book and thought about buying it myself recently.  If you have it, Rockessence, by all means let me know what you think of it - also if it is actually about Atlantis. A lot of books trade on it with the titlle then, go on and discuss something else, their own pet theories.
Report Spam   Logged
rockessence
Superhero Member
******
Posts: 1688


Using rocks and minerals to heal the earth and us.


WWW
« Reply #7 on: April 24, 2007, 02:00:33 am »

This book is a great read and I'm about halfway through.  Boreas said he read it in Swedish and that it tends to focus on the fact that he was considered "mad" by the end of his career.   Too bad the author had not heard of the Bock saga and Felice Vinci's  Homer in the Baltic.  There would be a ton of corroboration for Rudbeck.  Rudbeck was an expert in ancient Latin and ancient Greek and really nailed some amazing points.  I wrote some in the Vikings section.  check it out.   If I wrote all I had earmarked in the book, I would be here typing for two days!
Report Spam   Logged

ILLIGITIMI NON CARBORUNDUM

Thus ye may find in thy mental and spiritual self, ye can make thyself just as happy or just as miserable as ye like. How miserable do ye want to be?......For you GROW to heaven, you don't GO to heaven. It is within thine own conscience that ye grow there.

Edgar Cayce
majoramo
Full Member
***
Posts: 2


Understanding is believing.


WWW
« Reply #8 on: December 07, 2007, 08:29:02 am »

Hello Smiley

Athena asked: In some senses this expertly written book deserves much claim and attention. In fact were it not for the fact that here again the author strives assiduously to make Atlantis into a kingdom off the coast of northern Europe it would be a phenomenal work of scholarship. Why for instance would Plato be so specific: That Atlantis was just beyond the Pillars of Hercules - if in fact it was actually an island off the coast of modern Germany.

After the book The Baltic Origins of Homers Epic Tales by Felice Vinci, the answer to why Plato specifically placed Atlantis just beyond the Pillars of Hercules takes on a new meaning. As Odysseus was not, in fact, sailing in the Mediterranean, but in the Baltic and the North Sea, the Pillars of Hercules turns out originally to have been situated among the Faroe Islands.
Sailing along the currents of the Gulf Stream, the next place one would then encounter beyond the Faroe Islands would be the west coast of what was once an island, today consisting of Norway, Sweeden, Finland and Kola. As the ice age ended, the ice scraped away a lot of the landscape, but leaving the mountains of the Lofoten islands more or less intact. These mountains are today some of the oldest in the world, being some 3.5 billion years old, which should make them one of very few parts of Atlantis still in existence today the way they were in the times when Atlantis still existed…
Report Spam   Logged
Aristotle
Superhero Member
******
Posts: 4553



« Reply #9 on: December 07, 2007, 10:57:39 am »

The problem with placing Atlantis in the north is that it typically ignores the aspects that Plato gives it - a temperate climate, complete with elephants, two growing seasons, and sheltered from the north winds.

We tend to make Plato's elephants the mastodons or mammoths of the Ice Age, suitable for the time Plato sets it (9 to 10,000 bc) but the climate Plato suggests has never been satisfactorily explained by anyone who supports this theory.
Report Spam   Logged

"It is the mark of an educated mind to be able to entertain a thought without accepting it."
- Aristotle
rockessence
Superhero Member
******
Posts: 1688


Using rocks and minerals to heal the earth and us.


WWW
« Reply #10 on: December 07, 2007, 11:47:44 am »

As Felice Vinci points out in his book The Baltic Origins of Homers Epic Tales, The Climatic Optimum which ended, prompting the migrations south around 3000-2500BC, had the far north so warm that it was comparable to the grape growing regions of southern France today- judging from the remains of flora discovered there.  Far warmer in fact than the later "optimum" which accompanied the later Middle Ages.
Report Spam   Logged

ILLIGITIMI NON CARBORUNDUM

Thus ye may find in thy mental and spiritual self, ye can make thyself just as happy or just as miserable as ye like. How miserable do ye want to be?......For you GROW to heaven, you don't GO to heaven. It is within thine own conscience that ye grow there.

Edgar Cayce
Mark of Australia
Hero Member
*****
Posts: 703



« Reply #11 on: December 07, 2007, 12:39:18 pm »

Hi All ,

I think that 'The Mystery of Atlantis' by Charles Berlitz is easily the best book on Athena's list. It includes the relevant parts of Timaeus and Critias in full.

Plus Berlitz doesn't really put forward any theory, he just present the 'evidence' so you can make up your own mind. I like that.
Report Spam   Logged
Desiree
Superhero Member
******
Posts: 3882



« Reply #12 on: December 07, 2007, 01:14:54 pm »

Hi Mark, the book does have some good evidence in it. Berlitz reports everything he had heard of at the time about Atlantis and offers some pretty good leads!  The pictures are also very helpful.  The worst part (for me) is that so little has come from further investigation into any of that evidence.  Bummer!  Too bad deep Atlantic Ocean exploration is so costly.
Report Spam   Logged

This power came forth out of the Atlantic Ocean. But afterwards there occurred violent earthquakes and floods; and in a single day and night of misfortune all your warlike men in a body sank into the earth, and the island of Atlantis in like manner disappeared in the depths of the sea.
Mark of Australia
Hero Member
*****
Posts: 703



« Reply #13 on: December 07, 2007, 01:34:35 pm »

Hi Desiree ,

Yeah ,the cost of deep sea exploration is the main reason why Atlantis hasn't been found I think, it's just so prohibitive.

I can't for the life of me think of any other good Atlantis book because as Ian says, so many of the so-called Atlantis books merely cash in on the name but have very little of to do with Atlantis. Even 'When the Sky Fell-In Search of Atlantis' has nothing to do with Atlantis in my opinion. It's mostly about Earth Crust Displacement and Antarctica... the link between those things and Atlantis in the book comes down to a very wishful interpretation of a single ancient map ,The Kircher Map. Take that almost childish map comparison away and there is no reason whatsoever to mention Atlantis in that book ...and he doesn't really mention Atlantis much anyway ,certainly not the Atlantis of Plato .

Oh ,there is Zhirov's work ,' Atlantology - Basic Problems'  is probably second best in my opinion. I like that he was really trying to be scientific and considered Plato's story at face value.
« Last Edit: December 07, 2007, 01:37:12 pm by Mark Ponta » Report Spam   Logged
Bianca
Superhero Member
******
Posts: 41646



« Reply #14 on: December 07, 2007, 08:55:41 pm »







Thanks, Mark!!

Here's Amazon's revue and one by a reader, dhill757, who sounds a lot like OUR dhill:


                                         Editorial Reviews





Book Description



A Soviet scientist examines geology, climate, oceanography and attempts reconstruction of Atlantis. Illustrated with maps, charts, tables, illustrations, seismic data, sonar images, etc.

The fascinating age-old riddle of the legendary continent of Atlantis is a challenge to any investigator for it would be hard to name a problem of longer standing or one that has given rise to sharper controversies and differences of views and opinions. Some investigators have rejected it as a key to an ancient riddle throwing light on many aspects of human history and civilization. Thousands of books and papers have been devoted to the thrilling problem of Atlantis, and a new scientific trend, atlantology, studying Atlantis has emerged.

Atlantology cannot advance without the aid of geomorphology and marine geology, which are relatively new spheres of human knowledge. Indeed, the problems linked up with Atlantis can be approached successfully only by drawing upon the latest achievements of world science in the study of the geological structure and relief of the ocean bed, only in the light of the new ideas about the youth and active development of oceans.

The author believes that Atlantis existed and uses a great number of facts to back up his arguments. His work sums up much on what we know about atlantology. This book will unquestionably serve as the basis for elaborating on many aspects of one of the world’s most dramatic problems. Zhirov was a chemist by trade and a leading Soviet Atlantologist. The book was written between 1959-63. New data was added for this English edition. Seismics, gravimetrics, climatology, paleobotanical data, geomorphology, plate tectonics, turbidity data, bottom current patterns, submarine erosion and geological data separate this book from most of the rest of the Atlantology field. Cites 825 separate sources in 34 pages of references - Russian, Ukrainian, Greek, German, English, Latin...




--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------






                                                         Most Helpful Customer Reviews





   4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:



                                    One of the best books on Atlantis, September 24, 2003



By  D. Hill "dhill757"
     

While most books on Atlantis take a subjective view, this one leans clearly towards the scientific. This book looks at the topic of Atlantis from a geographical and geological viewpoint and amasses a large amount of evidence and expert opinions to prove that

(1.) Parts of the Mid-Atlantic Ridge were above sea level until about twelve thousand b.c.

(2.) Atlantis existed in the tropics. There is no attempt to place Atlantis at Santorini as many other books try to do, Zhirov placed Atlantis squarely in the Atlantic, just as Plato did.

If one reads Plato, and takes him literally, none of the other possibilities, like placing Atlantis on Thera, or in Indonesia, or any other place besides the Atlantic Ocean are possible (and yes, Plato knew where the Atlantic was and what the Straits of Gibraltar are).

Zhirov also offers what we know of the history of the Atlantic Ocean as well as the Mid-Atlantic Ridge and the book is illustrated with many black and white maps and diagrams. It is a great addition to any library dealing with Atlantis or the lost continents, but, also unlike other books like this, the author does not romance his topic.

Zhirov looks at the subject through cold geological facts, the same evidence that others try to use to discredit the theory, and concludes that Atlantis existed. It is a very important book written from a new point of view, a scientist's view. 
« Last Edit: December 07, 2007, 09:02:46 pm by Bianca2001 » Report Spam   Logged

Your mind understands what you have been taught; your heart what is true.
Pages: [1] 2   Go Up
  Print  
 
Jump to:  

Powered by EzPortal
Bookmark this site! | Upgrade This Forum
SMF For Free - Create your own Forum
Powered by SMF | SMF © 2016, Simple Machines
Privacy Policy