DEAR HORUS,Amateur historians call themselves Atlantologists, but took roman anachronisms into account as Plato's original Text. veryfying Plato's Atlantis means that the Roman/ latin anachronisms should be 'redressed'to the Greek originals.
Atlantis in Atlantic is a Fallacy ! Allready various( AR-) Forum members not in the least 'Georgeos' have pointed out that the AT-land-Sea was a side Brance off the Ocean-proper, thus the notion of Atlantic-Ocean is a fallacy of it's own.
Also
the island notion is false, I mean how bad are your Eyes, when you reaqd in TIMEAUS, that "Atlantis was
connected to the mainland by an Isthmus and still maintain that it was an Island(-Realm.) in Mid Atlantic or even farr off any Land-Coast ? ? I mean that this is not a ' common overlook 't his is shear stupidity.
The description of Atlantis Geology by Plato is far shorter than your account on Bimini yet even you failed to realise that Atlantis was a harbour-port constructed with land-based mountains in view in the North shielding it from the north-wind, and an outlet to sea in the south.
The mainstream Atlantologist of which You and Tom Herbert are an exponent are totally decepted by PLATO's wrong translation.
Atlantis beaches were washed by the socalled "
World-SEA "wich HERODOTUS a contemporary of Plato, equaited with the ' MARE-Erytraeum ' which today isnamed the Gulf-Of Aden and only by extention, also the Indian/Aranbic Sea.
Naturally ' Bimini' may have been involved in the last Great Global Tsunami THAT FLattened ATLANTIS AND BURRIED IT UNDER TONS OF AFFLUENT 50 METERS BELOW PRESENT SEA-LEVEL, but that's because it was a Global event of which the Egyptians said that they were not bothered by it because most of land-based-Egypt was in the 'Shadow' of the direction of the Tsunami-track.
I may be dubbed 'resident LOONEY, by TOM Herbert earlier, but his Malta-is Atlantis-Theory is nice but not the site of Atlantis. Differntly from the 'mainstream Atlantologists in Placing Atlantis in Malta he is adhering to the deviant theory that Atlantis isle was NOT'Bigger-than'but just in-between: Asia * Lybia'and thats ex-cludes the Atlantis in Atlantic fallacy.
Thus TOM Hebert cannot be a serious believer in Atlantis in America nor can Nikas & Mark-Ponte who also placed Atlantis on MALTA-isle as HALFWAY inbetween Asia & Lybia. It is a mystery to me why in flagrant contradition to everything PLATO indicated, people still look for Atlantis on the American continent.
IF it was understood that America and other sites were created by Atlantis-disaster refugies AFTER Aytlantis Demise, than none of the present Sites of a Possible Atlantis is the real one since Europe too was colonized by survivors of Atlantis AFTER the Demise.Take this from 'TOM's' Resident Looney':
It is the mainstream Atlantologists who spread deceptive theories and thus deceived themselves and the general Public, by not well-reading PLATO's SAGA, and making incomperable mistakes, that ' Georgeos ' at AR slowly revealed as not to disturb the Dream-theories of himself & others !
PRE-REQUISITE for ' ATLANTIS-finders ': Atlantis is now a City coverred with MUD( probably the RED-kind of Löss-version. One Kilometer thick at Ras-Aden at a depth of 200 meters in the Gulf.
In finding a Tsunami-victim-city such as Atlantis one would expect silt debris from the mainland heaped upon the site, is that ' pre- requisite' also the case with Bimini/ Bahama's ? ? Besides contrary to popular-believe, Atlantis or rather AD-Land, was built, inside a Vulcano caldeira.( now the Mud-Bay of Ras-Aden.)
The BIMINI rapports are very nice but CAYCWE & DONELLY were totally Biased by the America-LEAD that Chrostophore ' COLUMNs or Bust " Colon had followed At what he initially called" Atlantida "but later changed into"(West-)India'.)
Sincerely, '
Bluehue'
dd Sept. 25, 2007.
PSI would like you, to consider my 'Sub-Script( in
Blue.) at the post-bottom and ' Break THAT theory Down' please ! !
THANK YOU.
